The vacation rental industry has come a long way since it was first recognized as a separate lodging class in 1988. Today, this booming sector generated $17 billion in 2023 alone. The rapid growth has attracted attention from major tech firms, leading to the rise of household names like Airbnb and VRBO.
At Gulf Coast, property marketing is a critical aspect of our business. After all, if potential guests don’t know about our available vacation rentals, we can't generate revenue for our clients or commissions for ourselves. We advertise the vacation rentals we manage on various platforms, with bookings primarily sourced from direct channels or third-party listing sites, commonly known as Online Travel Agents (OTAs). While these listing sites may seem similar on the surface, key distinctions can significantly impact both homeowners and property managers.
Direct Bookings: Maximizing Control and Revenue
Direct bookings are those we secure without relying on third-party listing sites. These reservations mainly come through our websites, which showcase the properties we manage. Our online presence includes our main listing site, resort-specific websites, and websites dedicated to particular geographic areas or destinations. Repeat guests and referrals from our real estate partnerships also play a crucial role in driving direct bookings.
Securing a repeat guest who initially booked through a third-party site but then chooses to rebook directly with Gulf Coast is particularly rewarding. It indicates that both the property and our service exceeded expectations, building trust for future Florida vacations.
As of this year, direct bookings account for 72% of our revenue and 54% of our occupancy, with the remainder fulfilled by OTA reservations.
Merchant of Record: Protecting Your Revenue
When it comes to direct bookings, Gulf Coast serves as the 'Merchant of Record.' This means we handle all financial transactions, including deposits and final payments. In the event of a dispute, Gulf Coast has the authority to make the final decision, ensuring your rental income is protected according to our terms and conditions.
OTA Bookings: Broad Exposure with Managed Risks
We partner with over 70 listing sites, ranging from well-known platforms to niche sites targeting specific traveler types. Although there are over 1,000 third-party listing sites available, the market is dominated by four major players—Airbnb, Booking.com, Google, and VRBO.
Most of these platforms function primarily as advertising channels. Once a booking is made, the OTA charges a commission to Gulf Coast, collects any additional fees from the guest, and hands over the booking management to us. The reservation then falls under our terms and conditions, and Gulf Coast assumes the role of Merchant of Record. Generally, OTA bookings carry no more risk than direct bookings, with one notable exception—Airbnb.
The Airbnb Conundrum: High Exposure, Higher Risks
While VRBO (in its various iterations) was one of the original OTAs, Airbnb has revolutionized the way people think about travel accommodations. Airbnb has become synonymous with vacation rentals, much like Kleenex is with tissues, despite where the booking originates.
Although Airbnb was founded in California in 2007, it first gained prominence in Europe. Over the past few years, it has made significant strides in the U.S. market, with Airbnb surpassing VRBO in occupancy sales by over 30% in the last two years. We expect Airbnb’s market share to continue growing.
This success, however, comes with its challenges. Unlike direct bookings and most other OTAs, Airbnb insists on being the Merchant of Record, meaning they control the funds. While most trips proceed without issues, problems can arise, and when they do, Airbnb’s guest-centric approach often puts property owners at a disadvantage. We’ve seen instances where frivolous guest complaints are upheld by Airbnb, even when evidence contradicts the claims.
Additionally, Airbnb’s control over fund disbursement adds another layer of complexity. Unlike other platforms that transfer funds to us before the guest's stay, Airbnb releases funds only after the guest has checked in. If a booking spans the end of a month, it results in multiple disbursements, complicating our internal accounting and delaying payments to homeowners.
Airbnb’s approach to booking and cancellation policies also poses risks. The platform favors flexible cancellation policies, which can leave homeowners vulnerable to last-minute cancellations without compensation. This policy often conflicts with the stricter terms we have in place for direct bookings, potentially jeopardizing the homeowner's income.
Finally, guest reviews on Airbnb play a critical role in a property's success. Ratings above 4.5 stars are the gold standard, and a single negative review can significantly impact a property's performance and ranking. Unfortunately, some guests exploit this system, using the threat of a bad review to secure refunds or compensation, which we consider a form of blackmail.
Conclusion: Weighing the Benefits and Risks of Airbnb
Listing your property on Airbnb offers excellent exposure and the potential for increased revenue. However, this comes with significant risks that homeowners should carefully consider. At Gulf Coast, we recognize Airbnb as a valuable partner, but we advise property owners to be aware of the potential challenges. Over the years, we’ve developed strategies to mitigate these risks, ensuring we can maximize the benefits of listing on Airbnb while protecting our clients' interests.
.png)